From Forbes: "States Crack Down On Online Gene Tests"
Update: See the related story in GenomeWeb News (free sub. required).
Forbes.com published an article today entitled “States Crack Down On Online Gene Tests” that examines New York state’s response to the recent launch of direct-to-consumer (DTC) genetic testing services by companies such as 23andMe, deCODEme, SeqWright, and Navigenics, as well as the behind-the-scenes companies like Illumina and Affymetrix.
Unfortunately, the regulatory environment surrounding DTC genetic services is hazy at best. From the article:
“Over the last six months, New York State’s Department of Health has sent letters raising the specter of fines and jail time to six online gene-testing firms that offer consumers the ability to peer into their genome to assess their future risk of getting diseases such as cancer, heart disease and multiple sclerosis. Often, it turns out, the services offering these DNA deep-dives are doing so without the involvement of a doctor. That puts them on the wrong side of the law.”
Unclear Regulations
I’m still not convinced. I recently wrote an article that reviewed New York’s statutes and regulations regarding DTC testing, and it is far from clear. Additionally, there is almost an entire lack of case law to help interpret these statutes. Ultimately it is a question of statutory interpretation and legislative intent. What did the original drafters of these regulations intend the laws to do, or to protect? How should these laws be interpreted today? These are difficult questions without clear answers, and thus will be the subject of much debate in the near future.
P.S. – I am currently working to find a journal in which to publish my article, so stay tuned for my input on this very controversial topic!
April 19th, 2008 at 7:51 am
3.From Forbes: “States Crack Down On Online Gene Tests” The Genetic Genealogistwww.thegeneticgenealogist.com6 commentsSocialRank Forbes.com published an article today entitled “States Crack Down On Online Gene Tests†that examines New York state’s response to the recent launch of direct-to-consumer (DTC) genetic
April 18th, 2008 at 11:22 am
Blaine–
You say “Ultimately it is a question of statutory interpretation and legislative intent.” Of course, this is correct, in a perfect legal environment. Unfortunately, the reality is that it’s up to ambitious politicians or short-sighted bureaucrats or both, in the first instance to set up the limits.
Craig Manson’s last blog post..Texas Death Collection at FamilySearch Labs
April 18th, 2008 at 11:32 am
Craig – very good point. Something I almost wrote in the post is that I would rather see new legislation that specifically addresses these issues rather than trying to fit cutting-edge technology into decades-old law. But that is, of course, how the system works. It is unfortunate that scientists aren’t more involved in making policy (although I know that scientists are often consulted, I wonder how much influence they have on the process).
April 18th, 2008 at 2:13 pm
Or phsyicians!!!!
Seriously, I think a new “Spitzer” like lawyer will make big press by enforcing these laws designed to protect the consumer. I think we all need to be cognizant of the law regardless of our ideas on these topics…Otherwise, we get burned.
-Steve
http://www.thegenesherpa.blogspot.com
Steven Murphy MD’s last blog post..They Could’ve used the Sherpa!
April 18th, 2008 at 2:14 pm
As for the article. I have an idea…email me.
-Steve
http://www.thegenesherpa.blogspot.com
Steven Murphy MD’s last blog post..They Could’ve used the Sherpa!
April 18th, 2008 at 4:41 pm
[...] on this subject for quite some time now. It seems we all have been blogging about it. Today, Blaine points out an article at Forbes, which is further proof that someone is reading the Sherpa. Matt and Bob, sorry about [...]
April 22nd, 2008 at 10:31 am
[...] tinyMCE.init({ mode : “textareas”, theme : “simple” }); From Forbes: “States Crack Down On Online Gene Tests”linked to by 2 added on Fri 18th Apr 08 From Forbes: “States Crack Down On Online [...]
June 16th, 2008 at 6:08 pm
[...] States Crack Down On Online Gene Tests (www.thegeneticgenealogist.com) 1 point by thegeneticgenealogist about 1 month ago comment [...]
December 10th, 2008 at 8:04 pm
Great blog, found this very interesting, thanks