counter free hit unique web

Genetic Genealogy and the Amish

I am a genetic genealogist because I thought it would be a fun and interesting thing to do. Some people, however, are genetic genealogists because it is a matter of life and death.

amish1.jpg

The Amish/Mennonites and Genetic Disorders

The Amish migrated from Europe (Germany/Switzerland) to the United States in the 1700s. One such group, the Old Order Amish of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, began with 200 Swiss immigrants. Today, there are roughly 200,000 Old Order Amish. Because of the difficult lifestyle, the lack of evangelism, and the language barrier, there is essentially no conversion to the Amish religion. In addition, marriage outside the community is forbidden. As a result, the community has remained closed for over 10 generations and is still using the same 200 genomes of their founders! This is known as “founder effect,” which means that a population is started by just a small number of individuals and as a result that new population will be different (both genetically and phenotypically) from the parent population, potentially with low genetic variation.

If I were to sequence the genomes of 200 individuals that I had somehow randomly selected, I would undoubtedly uncover a number of undesirable mutations hidden in their genes. Most of these mutations would not cause any detectable phenotype because these individuals would still have a healthy copy of the mutated gene (for the DNA newbies, we all carry 2 sets of 22 chromosomes plus 2 sex chromosomes, meaning that we have two copies of most genes).

Within the Amish populations, the mutated gene perpetuates and flourishes because it is never diluted into the general public. This means that it becomes increasingly likely that two individuals, both carrying a copy of the mutated gene, will marry and produce offspring. These children then have a random chance of inheriting two mutated copies of the gene.

Crigler-Najjar Syndrome

A recent article in USA Today, “Blue glow signifies life in peril in Pennsylvania Dutch country” analyzes the effect of one of the genetic diseases threatening the Amish. Crigler-Najjar syndrome is extremely rare, with only about 110 known cases in the entire world. Almost 20% of those cases are among the Amish and Mennonite in Pennsylvania.

People with Crigler-Najjar syndrome are unable to break down bilirubin, a natural waste product from old blood cells, and it builds to a toxic level in their blood. Untreated, the condition leads to brain damage and death. The afflicted, with yellowed eyes and golden skin as a result of their condition, are forced to spend 10 to 12 hours a day in bed underneath bright blue lights to… These beds cost about $1,000, and fans must be used to keep the children cool under the intensity of the lights. Although there is no cure, a liver transplant is one option.

The Clinic for Special Children

In 1990 a clinic opened in Straburg that specialized in children with rare diseases. The Clinic for Special Children was founded by Dr. Holmes Morton, who once worked with Dr. John Crigler, the physician who first described Crigler-Najjar syndrome in 1952 with Dr. Victor Najjar. The building, located on a site that was once an Amish field, was erected by 70 local men in the traditional barn-raising manner.

According to Wikipedia:

The clinic treats about 600 children for 80 different genetic disorders or syndromes such as glutaric aciduria (GA1), maple syrup urine disease (MSUD), Crigler-Najjar syndrome (CNS), and medium-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency (MCADD). Not all the children are Amish; about 15% of the caseload come elsewhere, including Africa and Asia. About 75% of the children are treatable—and a third of those are highly treatable, many through techniques developed at the center

There’s a great brochure available that provides an in-depth description of the Clinic. In 2006, Dr. Morton was awarded a MacArthur Foundation “genius grant” for his work. A well-deserved honor, if you ask me. Here is a list of some of the publications associated with the Clinic for Special Children. Here are some other articles about the Clinic, including the Genome News Network, the New York Times, Scienceline, Affymetrix, and here. For more information about the Amish/Mennonites and genetic disorders, see this brief review by Laura Weeks (pdf!).

 

Interestingly, there is a Swiss Anabaptist DNA Project at FTDNA, but unsurprisingly there are very few samples so far. Another interesting source of information about Amish/Mennonite genetic genealogy is the Yoder Family Website, which contains links to DNA testing by members of the Yoder Family.

Hsien at EyeonDNA wrote about this topic at Genetics and Health, and if you read the article, you’ll see that even her “doctorate genealogy” has a link back to Amish studies.



  

6 Trackbacks

  1. By Smoky Mountain Family Historian on 31 December 1969 at 5:00 pm

    links from TechnoratiAmish and DNA. There is an interesting summary of results for the Yoder project. My Yoder line is 25126 in the numbering system utilized by the Yoder Newsletter. This is derived from the book Amish and Amish-Mennonite Genealogies

  2. […] explores genetic genealogy and the Amish, a population that has helped researchers identify many rare genetic mutations and […]

  3. Kramer auto Pingback[…] these days.  Anyone else find this observation to be true?Also of interest this week, an interesting post about Amish/Mennonites and genetic disorders with lots of links to other fascinating […]

  4. By Genetic Amish Studies - Dogpile Web Search on 9 April 2008 at 12:11 pm

    Kramer auto Pingback[…] … http://www.miami.edu/ummedicine-magazine/Spring2004/fstor... [Found on Yahoo! Search] 14. Genetic Genealogy and the Amish " The Genetic Genealogist I am a genetic genealogist because I thought it would be a fun and … you’ll see that even her […]

  5. Kramer auto Pingback[…] Author: bankbabeDate: 04/14/2008, 04:21 pmNeopatrick mentioned this on another thread about things that are simply WRONG, and I have to agree that the practice of polygamy and forcing young girls into marriage at a young age with a bed in the temple is something that I simply will never be able to udnerstand. If we have any fodorite FLDS people on this board, can anyone explain why this practice is in existance? Do we just chalk it up to the men being way way out of touch with reality all that is considered normal? I have not seen this discussed here, and I am not trying to knock another's religion, but is there a plausible explanation why this is accepted in the FLDS church? Some of these women that are interviewed appear to be brainwahsed to me… Author: ReisenderDate: 04/14/2008, 04:34 pm"women that are interviewed appear to be brainwahsed " yes they are indeed and the men are surely closet pedophiles that are lusting after young girls and claim to wait until the girls are into puberty before they "wed and bed" them (anyone believe that?). The whole thing is disgusting and the cloak of "religion" does not make it right. Lock them all up as far as I am concerned. Author: avalonDate: 04/14/2008, 04:42 pmI was just watching a segment on the Lost Boys of Polygamy. They turn these young men out on the streets, poorly educated and with no waqy to care for themselves or to live in modern society. And why? Because there are not enough young girls to go around to fulfill the many marriages..and I use that term loosely.. they are required. So it's not only young girls being abused but the young males as well. http://www.childbrides.org/boys.html You can also google "lost boys flds "for more info Author: gailDate: 04/14/2008, 04:45 pmHelp me out with something about polygamy. Assuming there are approximately an equal number of males and females in the world, one guy gets multiple woman to marry him. That leaves multple males with no woman to marry. What happens to those guys? Are there far more woman in this religion than men? Do the males undergo some procedure such that they are like neutered bees within a hive? And what happens to young males? The video I saw of the woman and children leaving showed primarily woman and female children. That poses an even scarier question. While many things in life that I disagree with I can still some the logic behind it. In this case, it is such a mystery to me that I am very curious. Author: gailDate: 04/14/2008, 04:46 pmavalon - you posted as I was - at least that gives me some answers to the more serious of my questions. Author: avalonDate: 04/14/2008, 04:47 pmHere's another link http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost_Boys_of_Polygamy What I don't understand is..polygamy is illegal. So why aren't these people stopped? I mean if I said my church believes in human sacrifice, they sure as hell, would stop me, religious freedom nit withstanding. In fact , these FLDS practices ar human sacrifice. Author: gailDate: 04/14/2008, 04:48 pmWhile polygamy may be illegal, co-habitation is legal in most jurisdictions. And many of these people referred to having spiritual marriages - I took that to mean non-state legal marriages. Author: ReisenderDate: 04/14/2008, 04:49 pmI guess we can assume that since there is also lots of inbreeding going on due to the limited number of little girls for the "husbands" that many of these people are also mentally defective or otherwise handicapped. Perhaps that explains how the women can be convinced so easily to stay. Author: GoTravelDate: 04/14/2008, 04:51 pmPolygamy is a "religious freedom" excuse for pedophiles to hide behind the bible. Polygamists have been excommunicated from the CLDS for a long time. Author: starrsDate: 04/14/2008, 04:52 pmgail, see the post above yours. Teen boys are sent away so that they do not compete with the older men. The more wives a man has, the more exalted he will be in heaven. So, the boys are…discarded. Author: GeorgeWDate: 04/14/2008, 04:56 pmThe government did the right things. Hopefully, prison time will be of long duration to deter any other perverts who use the pretense of the Mormon religion to take advantage of innocent girls. Author: PalenQDate: 04/14/2008, 04:58 pmHeck Joseph Smith who wrote the Book of Mormon would be in jail then Author: vjpblovesitalyDate: 04/14/2008, 04:59 pmWasn't Joseph Smith murdered in jail or something? Author: FainaAgainDate: 04/14/2008, 05:01 pmI watch those programs on TV. From what I understand, the children are torchured into absolute obedience from very early age. One woman who managed to escape with all her children, said her husband never punished her. Whatever punishment for any "wrongdoing" was due, it was applied to her children. This made her obidient very fast! The reason she decided to leave was that her older daughter was approaching 14 and would be married off. It very scary to run away from something unknown. What made us leave Russia? We couldn't take the life there any longer, and didn't want our children to be subjected to it. I feel those mothers go through something similar, even scarrier. Author: SallyCanuckDate: 04/14/2008, 05:46 pmPedophiles, plain and simple. And children who are brainwashed from birth that if they don't do what they're told, they won't get to heaven. There was a program on CBC last night about this - they interviewed the would-be "prophet" in Bountiful, B.C. His name is Winston Blackmore. His father was a pedophile, too. The kids/young women all look alike and dress in frumpy, shapeless dresses with the same hairdo - there were lots of little boys, all fair haired. But there did seem to be some younger couples holding hands likely the first of these young men's wives. One woman, who left, (she wrote a book: http://www.exmormon.org/mormon/mormon126.htm) said, when they asked about in-breeding, that some of the men, or one of them, studies animal husbandry (sp?). She also said there are charts to show when it's a good time to "sleep" with a certain woman. The government here seems to be afraid to do anything because of religious freedom which sickens me although they did have the AG of British Columbia on making some noises about child abuse. But that's probably all it was. The place seemed well off with herds of cows, lots of farm and construction equipment so I don't know if they go out and work in the area but it would cost plenty to feed so many. Here's a link about Bountiful. http://www.religioustolerance.org/lds_poly1.htm It's been allowed to go on since 1947. Author: crefloorsDate: 04/14/2008, 05:47 pmThe sheriff in that county in Texas said they couldn't go in until the complaint. They knew what was going on but could not enter. I'm only repeating what he said in an interview and what I read he said, in the paper. I don't know the laws of Texas or that county. Frankly, I didn't get it, but that's what he said. Seems they have not been able to locate the girl who made the call. Like said on another thread, the LDS Church banned polygamy so gain statehood. Most of the members of that church have abided by that. There have been a few "rogues" and they have been excommunicated when discovered. The others are not members of the LDS church and have formed their own "religious" groups, outside the regular church. It has gone on for a long time, and only recently..maybe last 10 years or so, has the pressure started to really come against some of these people and groups. They kept to themselves, and no one seemed to want to bother with them. This has got to be very tramatic for many of those women and girls. Some, I'm sure are grateful, but others, believe it or not, not so much. I really doubt there are any FLDS people on this board..of course it's cybor space..I can't no that for sure, but I don't think this is the type of "place" they would be. Author: LoveItalyDate: 04/14/2008, 06:15 pmHello bankbabe, in that most people "find" Fodor's due to an interest in travel I doubt that any members of the FLDS would be here on Fodor's. From the little I know it sounds like they normally do not even leave their compound or what ever it is called. And I doubt any women or children of the FLDS have access to a computer, again from the little I know it appears they are cut off from the world so to speak. IMO, a very vile and sickening situation. And I do not understand how these men of the FLDS have been able to get away with their practices. It is against the law, is it not? Author: sylvia3Date: 04/14/2008, 06:37 pmhttp://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/issues/2005-12-29/news/feature_full.html For in depth look at the inbreeding in these small communities. Author: SeamusDate: 04/14/2008, 06:46 pmit is a tragic situation, period. Without wanting to in any way suggest that this sort of child abuse is acceptable, it does shine a light on other practices which constitute abuse and yet are defended on religious grounds and socially accepted. What about ritual genital mutilation? Most agree that the practice of clitorectomy is unacceptable, but what about male circumcision? In many western cultures it is not only accepted but considered exempt from question because of the religious defense. Author: SallyCanuckDate: 04/14/2008, 06:53 pmWhat a terrible story. Author: jorrDate: 04/14/2008, 07:07 pmThe FLDS is an organization which attracts pedophiles IMO. Sick pedophiles who hide behind their version of the Bible in order to take advantage of children. Author: AnonymousDate: 04/14/2008, 08:53 pmThe link that sylvia posted, about the prevalence of a very rare genetic disorder due to inbreeding in an isolated community, is a classic case of "founder effect," in which everybody in town is a twig on the same family tree. Similar elevated rates of extremely rare genetic disorders are also found in other communities that are isolated by either choice or geography, including the Amish, who are a lot more open-minded about addressing the issue. http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/06/08/60II/main700519.shtml http://www.thegeneticgenealogist.com/2007/06/21/genetic-genealogy-and-the-amish/ […]

  6. Kramer auto Pingback[…] http://www.thegeneticgenealogist.co…-and-the-amish/ ^^ news articles about the Amish and their own genetic disorders, also the cause of years of […]

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*